Skip to content
A trader stands on a glowing intelligence layer beside an orange stream of light held at its surface, above a teal city of data.
Fixed income Execution intelligence

Not trading is a decision. Nobody records it.

Abdullah Hiyatt
Abdullah Hiyatt

Every experienced fixed income trader knows that some of the best decisions of the day are the trades they didn't do. The order that arrived as liquidity was drying up. The bond already shown to three dealers that morning. The size that would have moved the price against the fund just ahead of month-end.

Holding back, working an order more patiently or going back to the portfolio manager is part of the job. Nobody needs software to tell a good trader that.

What's missing is something else. The decision not to trade, or not yet, leaves almost no trace.

What gets measured is what got executed

Transaction cost analysis and best execution reviews are built around fills. They measure the price achieved against arrival, against a composite and against cover. That is useful, but it only covers the trades that happened.

An order that was held for two days, worked in smaller pieces or handed back to the PM produces no record of the reasoning, no evidence of the market at the time and no measured outcome. If that patience saved the fund twenty basis points, nobody can show it. If it cost the fund, nobody learns from that either.

Where that costs desks

The PM conversation. When a trader pushes back on an order, it usually comes down to experience against urgency. A trader with a strong record tends to win that argument, and a newer one often doesn't. Either way, the judgement is never written down.

Scale. A senior trader can hold the context for a handful of difficult bonds. Spread that judgement across a 200-line list, a volatile session or a colleague covering the book, and it thins out quickly.

Consistency. Two traders on the same desk can make opposite calls on the same order on the same day. Without a record, nobody sees it, and the desk can't settle which approach works.

Oversight. Compliance and best execution committees review what was executed. Decisions not to execute can matter just as much to client outcomes, but they rarely come into view.

What changes when "not yet" is recorded

Suppose the decision to wait, stage or escalate is captured at the moment it is made. Several things change.

The PM conversation becomes a discussion of evidence rather than a contest of opinions. Oversight extends to decisions, not only fills. And judgement that used to live in one trader's head becomes part of the desk's institutional memory, which doesn't walk out of the door when a trader moves on.

The trader still decides

None of this replaces judgement. The decision stays with the trader, and accountability stays with the desk. The point is to make good judgement visible, consistent and measurable, and to give the desk a way to prove it.

That is part of what Avarrai is building. It is an execution intelligence layer that treats waiting, escalating and not trading today as decisions in their own right, recorded with the same care as an executed trade.

We're looking for a small number of buy-side fixed income desks to work with as design partners. If your desk recognises this problem, we'd like to hear from you.

Share this post